
By Zhen Ming
IN his 2002 letter to his Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, billionaire investor Warren Buffett made headlines when he loudly condemned derivatives as "financial weapons of mass destruction".
These contracts sold to the world as a way to reduce risk were "time bombs, both for the parties that deal in them and the economic system", he strenuously asserted.
Back then, Buffett also made this gloomy prediction:
"The derivatives genie is now well out of the bottle, and these instruments will almost certainly multiply in variety and number until some event makes their toxicity clear. Central banks and governments have so far found no effective way to control, or even monitor, the risks posed by these contracts."
He did it too
But now the whole world has found out that Buffett had also allowed his insurance and investment conglomerate to make big (and disappointing) bets on derivatives.
On 7 Nov, Berkshire reported paper losses from derivative bets totaling US$6.73 billion at the end of the third quarter, causing the company’s shares to drop by 34.4 per cent in less than two weeks to a 52-week low of US$74,100 apiece.
When compared against their all-time record high of US$151,650 apiece, Berkshire shares had fallen by more than half by 20 Nov.
Berkshire shares have since then recovered by some 40 per cent to close at US$104,000 apiece on Friday after Buffett promised to tell all.
How did he err?
What went wrong for our 77-year-old Oracle from Omaha?
According to corporate filings, buyers of the derivatives would be entitled to billions of dollars from Berkshire if four stock indexes (including the Standard & Poor’s 500) drop below agreed-upon levels on dates beginning in 2019.
Berkshire explained it has contracts whose values depend on where the four stock indexes would trade between 2019 and 2027.
Berkshire also explained it could theoretically owe as much as US$37.04 billion on the contracts. But Buffett's follow-up email later said the four stock indexes would all have to fall to zero for Berkshire to be liable for the entire sum that's at risk.
You'll know next year
Acknowledging investor concern, Buffett said he will disclose more information on how he calculates losses on Berkshire's derivative bets in his next yearly letter to shareholders (expected around end-February).
The report will disclose "all aspects of valuation" and cover "deficiencies in the formula" for pricing the derivatives, "which we nevertheless use," Buffett said.
"If he'd stayed silent on this, the stock would have stayed at US$80,000," said Berkshire shareholder Michael Yoshikami.
Not surprisingly, in the past few months, Buffett has called on investors to begin investing in US stocks again, and has made a few high profile investments himself recently, including buying preferred shares of Goldman Sachs and General Electric.
Recovery — not so soon
Yet Buffett has also been equally candid about the downtrodden US economy. Although the Federal Reserve and others are suggesting that it will begin recovering in mid-2009, Buffett says it will take longer, and unemployment will continue to rise for some time.
"There are going to be more people unemployed," Buffett said during a Friday interview on Fox Business Network. "I'm not worried about five years from now. Five months from now, can be very painful," and "it will not turn around by mid-year next year."
In happier times, back on 23 Oct 2006, the price of a share of Berkshire became the first stock to ever close at the six-digit mark at US$100,000.
Back then, for the same US$100,000, you could buy a high-performance Mercedes-Benz CLS63 AMG coupe in America or a 74-day round-the-world cruise in a Royal Suite on the Queen Mary 2.
Back then, Buffett was hailed as the greatest investor alive. But his prior successes may have forced him to buy in billion-dollar chunks to impact Berkshire's bottom line.
This problem of too much cash for too few investing opportunities may have given rise to “cash intoxication” — resulting in Buffett's recent foray into currency and commodity speculation and even bets on derivatives.
Ironically, Buffett once said, "Wide diversification is only required when investors do not understand what they are doing."
Berkshire Hathaway’s Share Price Milestones
................................ Date ..................... Price per Share ... % Change
Average Cost1 .......... 1962 — 1963 ......... US$15 ................... NA
Six-Digit Record ........ 23 Oct 2006 .......... US$100,000 ....... + 666,567% (est)
All-Time High ............ 11 Dec 2007 .......... US$151,650 ....... + 51.6%
52-Week Low ............ 20 Nov 2008 .......... US$74,100 ........ - 51.1%
Latest Close ............. 28 Nov 2008 .......... US$104,000 ....... + 40.4%
1 Warren Buffett started accumulating Berkshire Hathaway shares in 1962 when they were less than US$8 apiece. By 1963, the average cost of his acquisition was estimated at around US$15 apiece whereas the company’s shares were then trading at about US$18 apiece.
Source: The New Paper, Sun 30 Nov 2008